Survivor: Palau

Hobie's Take on Season 10 of this amazing series!

Ep4: Will the Carnage Ever End?

Home | My Thoughts | Others' Rants | Links
Episodes:
Preshow | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4

Angie

Ashlee

Bobby Jon

Ibrehem

James

Jeff

Jolanda

Kim

Stephenie

I wish I could say it wasn't sad, but it just is

Good riddance to this useless castaway. Did Kim even last a second on the sumo pad? Who could have thought that this tribe would be so pathetic? I completely agree with Stephenie's and Angie's assessment of their predicament: They're doing all they can to win these challenges yet the guys, and Kim, just aren't able to contribute or perform. I can't believe Coby completely took James out both times, although Coby does have mass on his side. Anyways, farewell to Kim, who took on the proud title that Sarah of Marquesas had left available after she was voted out so many seasons ago. What's that title? Most Useless Survivor.

The Battle of the Better Bathroom

Was it even close? No. Koror's bathroom had style, had creativity, had functionality (the shower head that could adjust to height? Sweet.), and overall blew away Ulong's bathroom. Okay, Ulong's bathroom wasn't catastrophic, such as the way Rupert's undersea beach log cabin was on All Stars, but compared to Koror's, no contest.

Immunity Challenge - and now there were 4 straight losses

It's so hard to root for Koror. At least for me. I keep wanting the underdog to win, but the more that Koror wins and bonds and establishes a team unity, and the more that Ulong's morale plummets, it seems almost impossible for Ulong to overcome the odds. And how awesome are the Ulong girls (besides Kim)? Angie and Stephenie rock! 4 for 4. Amazing. Bobby Jon was against Tom, and he still tried valiantly, but Tom is just stronger, methinks. Ibrehem got his ass handed to him his first round, but that second round attack was impressive. And I've already mentioned how sad James' defeat was. Both times. So, Koror won a deserved immunity again, and we had to watch Ulong go to tribal council, again.

Tribal Council: Where even Jeff Probst is trying to help Ulong out

When Jeff Probst actually decides that he needs to help Ulong figure out where they're going wrong, you know you're in trouble. You know, I briefly thought the girls would do the girlpower thing and I'm glad they didn't. Don't worry about any male-female alliances just yet - just try to survive until the merge or swap or whatever happens. And to do that, Ulong had to get rid of completely useless baggage. So they properly voted out Kim. But dayum, will Ulong catch a break?

Final Thoughts

Based on the previews, it's plausible that next week (remember, next WEDNESDAY) we will see some sort of tribal shift. I don't think they'll equalize the tribes, as that would be somewhat unfair, but who knows? This definitely has not been the most 'fair' of Survivors, from the schoolyard ejection of Wanda and Jonathan to the amazing reward of a fully-rebuilt shelter. So it'll be interesting. I just really hope that Angie and Stephenie somehow make it far. It does seem that there are fractures in the Koror tribe, they just haven't been stressed yet. If so, Angie and Stephenie, if they play smart, could use that to their advantage and be the vote(s) to break the Koror teams. Needless to say, I'm still hooked.

Other's Thoughts:

C-Money speaks - It's On....:

So, Kimmy is already whinning because Jeff is gone. I hate her...

And we are swappin people already. Poor Cody, you are just NOW realizing that you are not part of the group? Duh! And even suggesting sending Kim from the Ulong, ha! They just want to get rid of her. Boy, Ian sure is a GEEK, eh? Look at his cheesy smile! So they are going to build a bathroom? What kind of challenge is that? Willard actually did something too? It's nice to actually see these people start working together (on both teams). Boy, Caryn sure is a beyotch isn't she? Tom is the guy who took charge and is a good leader, accept it and get over it, girl Do you think you could do a better job??? Step up then.

Kim thinks she the smart one???!! Holy crap! She is so useless!!! These people are working their asses off and working together and getting a job done while you just sit and watch. Of course people are going to argue and think they have better ideas than the others, but you know what? They have EARNED that right. They're working. What are YOU doing?

Now comes the judging. AND, Ulong isn't done yet??? Man, that's bad. Plus, Koror did a better job of selling the bathroom. Just waiting to see. Koror wins it. I figured they would. Poor Ulong, but they just didn't have to sturdiness the Koror tribe had. Let's hope that losing this one gets them going to win the immunity. Champagne to go with it too! Cool! Caryn, you are a GAY drunk too! Red Neck James, you tell 'em! You're gonna win the immunity challenge because of it. Be strong! Be Mad! Be Mean!!! Win! Win!!! WIN!!

Sumo wrestling for the immunity challenge? This ought to be fun. Some of these challenges are just too bloody. Heartless this time. Angie's got this one, NO PROBLEM!!! Kim did not EVEN try!!! What a BITCH! Ibrhem spoke again!! Come on RED NECK!!! Please, beat the gay guy... man, this SUCKS! I'm tired of seeing these guys lose. Koror needs to get rid of someone, well 2 someones. You know, next week they will have to redistribute the teams.

I will totally be disappointed in this tribe (Ulong) if they do not get rid of the useless, flakey, lazy Kim. I may not even watch it anymore if they don't vote her ass off. You would be SO STUPID to vote off one of the men, I'm not even going to dignify this with a rant...

Jeff, that was rude! "I saved your seats for you..." I would have gotten up and punched him in the neck!

Good job, got rid of the lazy one. I had no doubts this time. Even though CBS tried, I didn't even falter. Buh-Bye Kim!

BTW, say all kinds of prayers and cross everything, I'm testing Monday. I want to be a MSgt!!


Squirrel's Comments - Ep 4:

CHIME!

We had a comm problem. Figures, two comm guys having a comm problem. No biggie, I fixed it by having a hissy fit in the guest book. I feel better.

As for Survivor...
I'm glad the reward challenge was something simple. They've been physically grueling so at least this one relied upon some creativity and thought. I liked Ulong's bathroom design but it was a bit flimsy. At first I didn't like Koror's but then I starting thinking about it. It was a good idea to separate the shower and bathroom and I did like the adjustable shower head. That's an important detail for height challenged squirrels like me. So good on Koror. Poor Ulong, now they can't even win a reward challenge.

Of course Kim didn't help them at all.

Immunity challenge was cruel. I suspect the pairing of Red Neck James and Coby was completely on purpose and done in the hopes of sparking more controversy. Yep, the writers seem to be back.

Of course, Kim didn't help them at all. Again.

The editing would suggest a girl alliance forming. This is NOT the time for that. You're a dying tribe and you need to fix it and come together. Ulong is small and they need to weed out the dead wood. They would be suicidal if they got rid of anyone other than Kim.

Tribal council comes and.... Bye-bye Female Futher. (Kim reminds me of someone else I know.) It was smart that my girl Angie and Stephenie figured it out. Now Ulong is lean and if they can just pick a leader and come together, they can completely control the game. They can be a block of 5 that can tear apart the Koror block of 5 and 4. It's now their game to lose!

Overall,
I'll give it just another week.

TSHS


Links:

CBS Official Site: Ep4 - Still have to say that CBS is providing some amazing supplemental stuff to watch online, if you have a broadband connection that is. Visit and enjoy!

Ep4: Idiot (RNO) - Episode Recap; you gotta love this article title...I wonder who it's referring to?

Why Kim Lost (RNO)

Strategic Overview of Survivor, Episode 4: The Smug Shall Inherit the Tribe (RNO) - All is not lost for Ulong members if they realize the power they hold going into an unfavorable merge.

Caryn

Coby

Gregg

Ian

Janu

Jennifer

Katie

Tom

Willard